I'm Travis Penny, a Senior Mortgage Broker with Vision Mortgage in Portland, Maine. I started in 2004 and I'm still here. I'm a broker, not a bank, so I shop the loan across lenders instead of selling you one. I arrange DSCR rental loans in the 38 states on my Licensing page, and the refinance at the end of a BRRRR deal is one of those loans. That's why I wrote this.
The short answer. The BRRRR method is Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat. You buy a house that needs work, fix it, rent it, then refinance into a long-term rental loan based on the new value, and use the cash you get back for the next one. It works when the refinance was planned before the purchase. It fails when it wasn't.
How to use this page. Read Chapter 1 first. It walks one deal through every number. Then run your own numbers through the BRRRR calculator and Deal Stress Test. If you already own the property and want to know whether it's ready to refinance, use the Refinance Readiness Check. For the loans themselves, see my BRRRR loans page.
Everything here is free to read. If you want the printable version with the worksheets, the toolkit download is at the bottom.
Chapter 1. How BRRRR works, start to finish
I started in 2004 and I'm still here. I've watched a lot of investors try this method. The ones who make it work all do one thing early: they plan the refinance before they buy the house.
That's the whole secret. BRRRR isn't five steps. It's two loans that have to fit together, with a rehab and a tenant in the middle.
The five steps, the way a lender sees them
Buy. You buy a house that needs work, usually with cash, a bridge loan, a hard money loan, a seller note, or a partner's money. This first loan is short term and it costs you every month you hold it.
Rehab. You fix it. Real bids, a real budget, a cushion for what you'll find behind the walls. The appraiser later has to see a finished house that someone could move into today.
Rent. You get a rent number. A signed lease, or the appraiser's market rent estimate on a vacant house. That's the 1007 rent schedule. The program usually uses the lower of the two.
Refinance. A long term DSCR loan pays off the first loan. DSCR loans qualify on the property's rent, not your W-2. If the house appraised high enough, you get some of your cash back.
Repeat. That cash goes into the next deal.
Here's the part nobody likes to hear. The refinance decides everything. A great rehab with a bad refinance is just an expensive way to tie up your money.
One deal, every number shown
This is an illustrative example. It's not a real client, a quote, or a promise of what any program will do. There's no interest rate in it. Where a payment is needed, I use a payment figure you'd replace with the payment from your own loan scenario. The program limits (75% loan-to-value, 6 months of reserves) are placeholders to show the math, not terms I'm offering.
Step 1. What it cost to get in
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Purchase price | $150,000 |
| Purchase closing costs | $4,500 |
| Rehab | $40,000 |
| Holding costs: $1,800 a month for 6 months (bridge payment, taxes, insurance, utilities while it's empty) | $10,800 |
| All-in cost | $205,300 |
$150,000 + $4,500 + $40,000 + $10,800 = $205,300.
Step 2. How much of that was your cash
Say the bridge loan covered part of the price and the rehab draws, and the payoff when you refinance is $160,000.
Cash you put in = all-in cost minus the bridge payoff. $205,300 - $160,000 = $45,300.
Step 3. What it's worth after the rehab
Three renovated houses nearby sold in the last six months. They support a value of $250,000. That's the after repair value, and it's the appraiser's call, not yours.
Step 4. The new loan
The program in this example lends up to 75% of the appraised value on a cash-out refinance. $250,000 x 75% = $187,500.
Step 5. Cash back at closing
New loan, minus the payoff, minus refinance costs. Say the refinance costs are $6,000 (appraisal, title, recording and the rest, all illustrative). $187,500 - $160,000 - $6,000 = $21,500 back to you.
Step 6. Cash left in the deal
Cash you put in, minus cash you got back. $45,300 - $21,500 = $23,800 still in the house.
That's a good BRRRR. Not a perfect one. Most aren't. Anyone who tells you every deal gets all your money back hasn't closed many of them.
Step 7. Does the rent carry the loan? (the DSCR test)
The tenant signed a lease at $2,200. The appraiser's market rent came in at $2,150. Most programs use the lower number. Qualifying rent: $2,150.
The full monthly payment, called PITIA:
| Line | Monthly |
|---|---|
| Principal and interest (your number from your own loan scenario; not a rate quote) | $1,250 |
| Property taxes: $3,000 a year / 12 | $250 |
| Insurance: $1,800 a year / 12 | $150 |
| Flood | $0 |
| HOA | $0 |
| PITIA | $1,650 |
DSCR = qualifying rent / PITIA. $2,150 / $1,650 = 1.30.
At 1.00 the rent covers the payment exactly. Below 1.00 it doesn't. At 1.30 there's room.
Step 8. Break-even rent
The rent that just covers the payment is the PITIA itself: $1,650. If a program wanted 1.25, you'd need $1,650 x 1.25 = $2,062.50. You're above both.
Step 9. Reserves
The example program wants 6 months of PITIA in the bank after closing. $1,650 x 6 = $9,900. Know where that money is before you start. Don't plan on finding it.
Step 10. Your cash flow (this is not the lender's test)
DSCR programs generally don't subtract vacancy, repairs or management. You should.
| Line | Monthly |
|---|---|
| Rent actually collected | $2,200 |
| Minus PITIA | -$1,650 |
| Before set-asides | $550 |
| Vacancy set-aside, 5% (my assumption, change it) | -$110 |
| Repairs, 5% | -$110 |
| Big-ticket replacements (roof, HVAC), 5% | -$110 |
| If you manage it yourself | $220 |
| Management, 8% | -$176 |
| If you hire a manager | $44 |
Read that last line twice. A deal can pass the DSCR test and still put almost nothing in your pocket. BRRRR is mostly an equity and velocity play. Know which one you're buying.
Now break it on purpose
Same deal. One thing goes wrong at a time.
| What goes wrong | The new number | Cash back (or what you bring) | Cash left in the deal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nothing (base case) | Value $250,000 | $21,500 back | $23,800 |
| Appraisal 10% low | Value $225,000, loan $168,750 | $2,750 back | $42,550 |
| Appraisal 15% low | Value $212,500, loan $159,375 | You bring $6,625 | $51,925 |
| Appraisal 20% low | Value $200,000, loan $150,000 | You bring $16,000 | $61,300 |
| Rehab 20% over, paid from your cash | +$8,000 in | $21,500 back | $31,800 |
| Refinance 60 days late | +$3,600 holding | $21,500 back | $27,400 |
| Program uses cost, not value, because you haven't owned it long enough | Value used $190,000 (price + rehab), loan $142,500 | You bring $23,500 | $68,800 |
And the rent side:
| Rent | Qualifying rent | DSCR |
|---|---|---|
| As planned | $2,150 | 1.30 |
| 10% lower | $1,935 | 1.17 |
| 15% lower | $1,827.50 | 1.11 |
Look at the 10% appraisal miss. Nothing dramatic happened. The appraiser just picked a different comp. And $18,750 more of your money is stuck.
Look at the last row of the first table. That's seasoning. On some programs, if you haven't owned the house long enough, they lend on what you paid plus documented rehab, not on the new value. In this deal that flips $21,500 back to you into $23,500 you have to bring. A few programs have a shorter wait, usually at a smaller loan. Either way, you need to know which rule your refinance is under before you sign the purchase contract.
Run your own deal through the Deal Stress Test before you make an offer. It does every row above with your numbers.
What I'd want to see on this deal
Send me the address, what you paid or will pay, the rehab scope and bids, your value estimate with the three comps, the lease or the rent comps, the tax bill as an investor would pay it, a real insurance quote, your payoff and the maturity date on the first loan, and how title is held. With that, I can tell you where it's thin.
Text me at (207) 615-7770 or send it through the Refinance Readiness Check.
Chapter 2. The 10 ways a BRRRR refinance dies
Most BRRRR deals that go wrong go wrong at the refinance. And almost every refinance problem I've seen was sitting in plain sight before the purchase. Here are the ten I see most, and the check that catches each one before you buy.
I'm not going to pretend I can rank them by percentage. I don't have a clean statistic on that and I won't make one up. These are the ones that show up on real files.
1. The appraisal comes in under your number
How it kills the deal. The loan is a percentage of the appraised value. Every dollar the appraiser takes off your value comes off the loan at the same percentage. In Chapter 1, a 10% miss cost $18,750.
The check before you buy. Pull three renovated sold comps from the last six months, close by, same bed and bath count, similar size. Not listings. Sold. Then underwrite the deal at 90% of that value. If it only works at 100%, it doesn't work.
2. The rent comes in under the DSCR line
How it kills the deal. The appraiser's market rent, the 1007, is usually what the program uses, or the lease if it's lower. If your plan assumed the best rent in town, the ratio drops and the loan shrinks or dies.
The check before you buy. Use leased comps, not asking rents. Run the deal at 90% of that rent. Know your break-even rent (the PITIA) before you write the offer. If the 90% rent doesn't clear the program minimum, walk or renegotiate.
3. You haven't owned it long enough (seasoning)
How it kills the deal. Some programs won't use the new appraised value until you've owned the property a set number of months. Before that, they lend on what you paid plus documented rehab. On a BRRRR, that can wipe out the cash-out completely.
The check before you buy. Know the seasoning rule of the refinance you're targeting before you sign the contract. Set the first loan's term to run past it, with room. On most of the programs I use today, that wait is 6 months, counted from the day you took title to the day the new loan closes. Under 6 months, cash-out generally works only if you bought with cash, and then the loan is based on the lower of the appraised value or what you paid plus documented rehab. Chapter 4 walks through it.
4. Taxes or insurance come in way over budget
How it kills the deal. Taxes and insurance are in the payment. A tax bill that resets after the sale, or an insurance quote that doubles, raises PITIA and drops DSCR. In some states a rental loses the seller's homestead treatment, and a big rehab can trigger a reassessment. Florida is the worst for this, and my Florida DSCR page walks through it.
The check before you buy. Get a real landlord insurance quote before the offer, not after. Check the flood zone on the FEMA map. Estimate taxes the way they'll be billed to an investor after the sale and the rehab, not from the seller's bill.
5. The rehab ate your reserves
How it kills the deal. Programs want a set number of months of the full payment in the bank after closing. If overruns ate that money, you can pass every other test and still not close.
The check before you buy. Carry a 15% contingency on the rehab. Keep your reserve money in a separate account you don't touch for the rehab. Treat it as already spent.
6. Title doesn't match, or there's a cloud on it
How it kills the deal. You bought in your own name and want to refinance in an LLC. Or the reverse. Or there's a contractor lien, an old judgment, or an open permit. Moving title can need a deed change and may restart seasoning. Some states require the DSCR loan to close in an entity. On my list, Georgia, New York and Virginia close in an LLC or corporation, and Montana closes in an LLC only.
The check before you buy. Buy in the name that will borrow on the refinance. Set up the LLC before the purchase contract. Have title search liens and open permits at the purchase. Collect lien waivers from every contractor at every draw.
7. The property isn't finished, or isn't eligible
How it kills the deal. The appraiser has to see a finished, rentable house. Missing appliances, unfinished flooring, no certificate of occupancy where one is needed: any of it can cut the value or stop the appraisal. And some properties never fit: mobile and manufactured homes, more than 9 units on the DSCR programs I arrange, some condos, and properties listed for sale recently.
The check before you buy. Confirm the property type, unit count and, on a condo, the building's status before the offer. Finish the rehab completely before you order the appraisal. Close the permits. If you listed it for sale during the rehab, tell me before we order anything.
8. Your credit drops during the rehab
How it kills the deal. Rehab materials on personal credit cards push utilization up, and scores drop. A lower score can mean a smaller loan or a program you no longer fit.
The check before you buy. Keep materials off personal cards. Pay contractors from the business account. Check your scores 60 days before the planned refinance so there's time to fix anything.
9. The first loan comes due before the refinance closes
How it kills the deal. Bridge and hard money loans have hard maturity dates. If the rehab or the appraisal slips, you can be in default while you wait, with extension fees or worse. This is the one that turns a good deal into a fire drill.
The check before you buy. Build at least three months of buffer between the planned refinance date and the maturity date. Get the extension terms in writing at the purchase. Start the refinance conversation with me when the rehab starts, not when it ends.
10. The lease is a problem
How it kills the deal. A vacant house can usually refinance on the appraiser's market rent. But some leases cause trouble: a relative or a business partner as the tenant, a lease far above market that the program won't use, a short term rental with no history, or a property where local rules or the HOA don't allow the rental you planned.
The check before you buy. Decide long term or short term before the offer. If it's short term, check city, county and HOA rules first and plan to qualify on long term rent if you have to. Rent at market to an arm's-length tenant. Keep the signed lease and proof the deposit was received.
The short version
Underwrite at 90% of value and 90% of rent. Know the seasoning rule. Get the real insurance quote and the investor tax number. Keep reserves untouched. Buy in the right name. Finish the house. Watch your credit. Leave three months between refinance and maturity. Rent it at market.
Do those things and the refinance is a formality. Skip them and it's a coin flip.
Run your deal through the Deal Stress Test, or send it to me through the Refinance Readiness Check and I'll look at it myself.
Chapter 3. DSCR in plain English
The refinance at the end of most BRRRR deals is a DSCR loan. DSCR stands for debt service coverage ratio. Ignore the name. It's one division problem.
DSCR = qualifying rent ÷ PITIA
PITIA is the whole monthly payment: principal, interest, taxes, insurance, and association dues. Flood insurance goes in too if the house needs it. Leave any of those out and the ratio lies to you.
Qualifying rent is the rent the program will count. On a refinance it's usually the lower of the signed lease and the appraiser's market rent on the 1007 rent schedule. If the house is vacant after the rehab, the market rent is often used on its own. Some programs want to see the rehab was just finished before they'll do that. A lease above market rarely helps you. A lease below market almost always hurts.
What the number means:
- 1.00 means the rent pays the full payment and nothing else.
- Below 1.00 means it doesn't. Some programs still lend down to about 0.75, but with a smaller loan and more scrutiny.
- Above 1.00 gives you room. The higher it is, the more programs fit and the better the terms tend to be.
Break-even rent is the rent that makes the ratio exactly 1.00, which is just the PITIA. If a program wants 1.25, multiply the PITIA by 1.25. Know that number before you make an offer, and compare it to leased comps, not asking rents.
What the ratio doesn't do: it doesn't subtract vacancy, repairs, capital replacements or management. That's why the cash flow table in Chapter 1 is separate. The lender is asking "does the rent carry the debt?" You should also be asking "does this house make me money?"
One more thing about the payment. I don't put an interest rate on this page or in the calculator. The rate depends on the program, credit, loan size, property, and the day. Use the payment from your own loan scenario. If you don't have one, ask me for one on your actual deal.
Chapter 4. Seasoning: when the new value counts
This is the rule that quietly decides more BRRRR deals than any other, so it gets its own chapter.
Seasoning is how long you've owned the property before the refinance. Most DSCR programs won't lend on the new, higher appraised value until you've owned the house for a set time. On most of the programs I use today, that's 6 months, counted from the day you took title to the day the new loan closes.
Before 6 months. Cash-out generally only works if you bought the house with cash and there's no loan on it. That's called delayed financing. Even then, the loan is based on the lower of the appraised value or what you paid plus documented rehab, and it can't be more than the cash you actually put in. Bought with a bridge or hard money loan? Under 6 months you're usually limited to paying it off, not taking cash out.
Between 6 and 12 months. The appraised value usually counts. Some programs trim the maximum loan-to-value a little in that window, and the appraiser has to support the jump in value with the work that was done. Receipts and before photos matter here.
A few exceptions. Some programs have a shorter wait. At least one has almost no wait but lends a much smaller share of the value. They exist. They're usually not where the best cash-out is.
What it means in dollars, using Chapter 1: at 6 months, the loan is 75% of $250,000, or $187,500, and you get $21,500 back. If the cost basis is used instead, it's 75% of $190,000, or $142,500, and you bring $23,500 to closing. Same house. Same rent. A $45,000 swing from the calendar.
How to plan around it:
- Pick the refinance program before you buy, so you know the wait.
- Set the first loan's term to run at least three months past the date you'll hit it.
- Buy in the name you'll refinance in. Some programs count time owned by your LLC toward seasoning, and some don't. Changing names later can restart the clock.
- Don't list it for sale. Cash-out usually isn't allowed if the house was listed for sale in the last 6 months.
The Readiness Check asks for your purchase date and shows you which side of the line you're on.
Chapter 5. Funding the first deal without fooling yourself
Every BRRRR deal needs money in two places: getting into the house, and carrying it until the refinance. Here's the honest short list, roughly from least risky to most.
Your own cash. The cleanest. Nobody to pay back, and if you bought with cash, the delayed financing rule in Chapter 4 can let you pull it back out sooner.
Equity in a home you already own. A HELOC or a cash-out refinance on property you own can fund a purchase and rehab. The catch is that the loan on your house is now riding on the rental deal. If the refinance comes in light, you still owe it.
Retirement money. A 401(k) loan, a withdrawal, and a self-directed IRA are three very different things with very different taxes, penalties and rules about who can touch the property. Talk to a CPA before you move a dollar. I mean that literally.
The seller. Some sellers will carry a note, especially on houses that need work and have no mortgage. Ask plainly: "Would you consider taking part of the price over time?" Get the note's payoff terms in writing, and make sure it can be paid off at the refinance without a penalty.
A partner. The money partner who doesn't want to do the work. Put it in an operating agreement before the purchase: who puts in what, who signs and personally guarantees the DSCR loan, and how the cash from the refinance gets split. Most DSCR programs want the people who own the LLC on the loan.
Bridge, hard money and private money. Short-term loans built for buy-and-fix. They cost more and they come due fast. The DSCR loan at the end doesn't pay for the rehab. The rehab gets paid by this loan or by your cash. How much of the purchase and rehab a short-term lender will cover depends on the program, your experience and the after-repair value. I'll tell you what fits your deal rather than put a percentage on a web page.
Live in it first. Buying a 2 to 4 unit to live in, then renting it later, uses an owner-occupied loan, not a DSCR loan. I only do owner-occupied loans in Maine and Florida.
Whatever you use, write down the payoff and the maturity date on day one. Chapter 2, number 9, is why.
Chapter 6. LLC or personal name
DSCR loans are business purpose loans on investment property. A lot of them close in an LLC. Some states require it on the programs I arrange:
- Georgia, New York and Virginia: LLC or corporation, not your personal name. In New York the loan is business purpose only, on non-owner-occupied property.
- Montana: LLC only.
- Everywhere else on my list: your name or an LLC, confirmed file by file.
Even when it's optional, decide before you buy. The name on the purchase deed should be the name on the refinance. Deeding the house from you to your LLC right before the refinance can raise title questions and, on some programs, restart seasoning. You'll personally guarantee the loan either way, so the LLC is about liability and bookkeeping, not about keeping your credit out of it.
Get the LLC formed, the EIN issued and the operating agreement signed before the purchase contract. Talk to your attorney about the structure. I'm not one.
Chapter 7. Appraisal day
The appraiser decides two numbers that make or break the refinance: the value and the market rent. You can't control their opinion. You can control what they see.
- Finish everything. Appliances in, flooring done, paint done, every room usable. "Almost done" reads as unfinished.
- Close the permits. Open permits can stop the appraisal or the loan.
- Leave a one-page list on the counter: the work done, with dates and costs, and three renovated sold comps from the last six months that you think are fair.
- Have the lease and the deposit receipt ready, or your leased rent comps if it's vacant.
- Be there, briefly. Unlock it, answer questions, leave. Don't argue the value.
If the value comes in low, it's not always the end. A reconsideration of value with better comps sometimes works. Sometimes the answer is a smaller loan and more cash left in the deal. The Deal Stress Test shows you that number before it happens.
Chapter 8. The 90-day refinance timeline
Start the refinance when the rehab starts, not when it ends. Here's the order I'd want it in:
- 90 days out: tell me the plan. I'll run it at 90% of your value and 90% of your rent, and we'll check the seasoning date against your loan's maturity date.
- 60 days out: check your credit. Get the landlord insurance quote, and flood if needed. Line up the lease, or start marketing the unit.
- 45 days out: rehab done, permits closed. Gather the settlement statement from the purchase, rehab invoices, the payoff letter request, LLC documents and bank statements for reserves.
- 30 days out: application and appraisal order.
- Closing: the DSCR loan pays off the short-term loan, and any cash back comes to you.
Leave at least three months between the planned refinance and the date your first loan comes due. Something always slips.
Frequently asked questions
What is the BRRRR method? BRRRR stands for Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat. You buy a property that needs work, renovate it, rent it, refinance into a long-term rental loan based on the new value, and use the cash you get back for the next deal. The refinance at the end is usually a DSCR loan, which qualifies on the property's rent instead of your personal income.
How long do I have to own the house before a BRRRR cash-out refinance? On most of the DSCR programs I use today, 6 months from the day you took title to the day the new loan closes. Before that, cash-out generally works only if you bought with cash, and the loan is based on the lower of the appraised value or your purchase price plus documented rehab. A few programs have a shorter wait, usually with a smaller loan.
How much can I borrow on the refinance? It's a percentage of the appraised value, called loan-to-value. The examples on this page use 75% for a cash-out refinance as an illustration. The real number depends on the program, credit, the rent ratio, property type and loan size. It's not an offer.
Does the DSCR loan pay for the rehab? No. The DSCR loan is the long-term loan at the end. The rehab is paid by your cash or by a short-term bridge, hard money or private loan, and the DSCR refinance pays that loan off.
What DSCR do I need? Most programs I use look for 1.00 or higher, meaning the rent covers the full payment including taxes, insurance and dues. Some go lower, down to about 0.75, with a smaller loan.
Do you lend in my state? I arrange DSCR loans in 38 states: Alabama, Alaska, Arkansas, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, New Hampshire, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin and Wyoming. Not Arizona, California, Idaho, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, North Dakota, Oregon, Rhode Island, South Dakota, Utah, Vermont or Washington, DC.
Disclosures. This playbook is general education. It's not legal, tax or investment advice, and it's not a loan offer, a rate quote, an approval or a commitment to lend. Examples are illustrative and use placeholder program limits. Talk to a local attorney about your situation, and to a CPA or tax advisor before you move retirement or inherited money. DSCR loans are business purpose loans on non owner occupied investment property only. Program terms and availability change. Not everyone will qualify. I arrange DSCR loans in the 38 states on my Licensing page and residential loans in Maine and Florida only. Travis Penny is a mortgage broker, not a lender. Loans are arranged through Vision Mortgage, LLC, 352 Warren Avenue, Suite 6, Portland, ME 04103.
Travis Penny, Senior Mortgage Broker, NMLS 1649161 | Vision Mortgage NMLS 1286953 | Equal Housing Opportunity

