
BRRRR Strategy: Pick the Refinance First, Then the House
Most people learn BRRRR as five words: buy, rehab, rent, refinance, repeat. That's the method. The strategy is the part that decides whether you get your money back, and it starts at the end. Before I care about the kitchen, I want to know what the refinance will look like on the day you need it.
I arrange DSCR loans on rental property in 38 states, and every BRRRR deal I see ends in one. So this post is about strategy from the lender's side of the table: which number to track, how to pick a deal backward from the refinance, and when BRRRR is the wrong plan. If you want the full start-to-finish walkthrough, that's my BRRRR method guide. If you already have a deal, put it in the BRRRR calculator as you read.
The one number I track: money left in the deal
Investors love to quote cash-on-cash return and after-repair value. Both matter. But the number that tells you whether you can repeat is simpler:
Money left in = the cash you put in, minus the cash the refinance hands back.
If that number is close to zero, your money is free to go into the next house. If it's $40,000, you own a nice rental and you're done buying for a while. Neither is a failure. They're just different strategies, and you should know which one you're running before you close on the purchase, not after the appraisal.
Work backward from three things the refinance checks
The long term loan at the end looks at three things. You control almost none of them once the rehab is done, so test them before you buy.
1. What the house will appraise for. The appraiser compares your house to recent sales of similar renovated homes nearby. Not your budget, not the list price down the street. If there aren't two or three finished, sold comps that look like your after-repair house, your value is a guess.
2. What rent the program will count. Qualifying rent is usually the lower of your signed lease or the appraiser's market rent. A lease above market doesn't raise the number. A lease below market does lower it. The rent has to cover the full payment, meaning principal, interest, taxes, insurance and any association dues. On most programs I use, that ratio needs to be 1.00 or better for the best terms.
3. The calendar. On most current DSCR programs I work with, you need to own the property about 6 months before the new appraised value counts for a cash-out. Before that, cash-out generally only works if you bought with cash and there's no loan on the house, and the loan is sized on what you paid plus documented rehab. I wrote a separate post on that path: delayed financing on an investment property.
A worked example
This is an illustrative example, not a client file, a quote or an offer. The 75% figure is a program limit I use to show the math. Your file could land lower.
A two unit in a working-class neighborhood:
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Purchase | $118,000 |
| Closing costs on the purchase | $4,000 |
| Rehab | $52,000 |
| Carrying costs while vacant | $7,200 |
| All-in cost | $181,200 |
A short term loan covered most of the purchase and the rehab draws. The payoff at refinance is $150,000. So the investor's own cash in the deal is $181,200 minus $150,000, or $31,200.
At month 7, it appraises at $240,000. A cash-out refinance at 75% of value is a $180,000 loan. Take out the $150,000 payoff and about $6,500 in refinance costs, and $23,500 comes back.
Money left in: $31,200 minus $23,500 = $7,700.
That's a strong BRRRR. Now change one thing. The appraisal comes in at $220,000 instead. The loan drops to $165,000, the cash back drops to $8,500, and money left in jumps to $22,700. Same rehab. Same rent. One appraisal.
This is why I tell people to run the bad version first. The deal stress test does it for you: value at 90%, 85% and 80% of your number, rent down, rehab over budget and a 90 day delay, all shown in dollars.
A quick rule of thumb that is just arithmetic
If the program lends 75% of the appraised value, the most it can ever return is 75% of value. So if your all-in cost is more than 75% of a realistic after-repair value, some of your money stays in the house no matter how well the rehab goes.
In the example, 75% of $240,000 is $180,000, and the all-in was $181,200. Close to the line, which is why almost all of the cash came back. Push the all-in to $200,000 on that same value and you've left about $20,000 or more in before you've signed a lease.
That's not a reason to pass on a deal. Plenty of investors are happy leaving some cash in a property that rents well. It's a reason to decide on purpose.
Three ways investors fund the front half, and what each does to the back half
All cash. Cleanest file. You can use delayed financing in the first 6 months, but the loan is based on your cost, not the new value. Wait past 6 months and the new value counts.
A short term rehab loan. Most common. It covers the rehab you can't pay for in cash, because the DSCR loan at the end doesn't pay for rehab. Before 6 months you can usually only pay this loan off, not pull cash out, so the loan's term has to run well past your seasoning date.
Equity from another property. A HELOC or cash-out on a house you already own. Fast and flexible, but if the BRRRR refinance comes in light, you still owe that line. If you want to keep your primary home out of it, look at a DSCR HELOC on a rental you already own.
When BRRRR is the wrong strategy
I'd rather tell you this before you buy.
- The spread isn't there. If the realistic after-repair value is barely above what you'll have in it, you're buying a rental with extra steps. That can still be a good rental. Just call it that.
- You need the cash back in 90 days. The calendar rule makes that hard unless you paid cash, and even then you get your cost basis, not the new value.
- The rent can't carry the payment. If market rent won't cover the full payment at a 1.00 ratio, the refinance either shrinks or needs a lower loan amount. Check the rent with real leased comps, not a listing site guess.
- The plan is a short term rental. Most refinance programs want 12 months of rental history before they'll count nightly income, and they typically cap the loan lower, around 70% of value. A brand new Airbnb is a hard BRRRR.
Repeating without tripping over the rules
The "repeat" step has its own fine print.
- Each property needs reserves. Programs typically want 3 to 6 months of the full payment in the bank after closing, and the cash-out money can usually count toward it.
- Recent cash-out counts again. If you pull cash on a property and refinance it again within 12 months, many programs treat that as another cash-out.
- Big cash-outs have a ceiling. Above 60% of value, some programs cap the cash at $500,000. Most BRRRR deals never get near it, but small multifamily can.
- Stay in one name. Buy in the name you'll refinance in. Switching from your personal name to an LLC midstream can restart the clock on some programs. Some states on my list require an LLC, which is covered on each state page.
Before you put the next one under contract, run the Readiness Check. It takes the purchase date, the payoff, the rent and the value and tells you whether you're ready now, close, or not yet, with the dollar gap.
FAQ
What is the BRRRR strategy in real estate?
BRRRR stands for buy, rehab, rent, refinance, repeat. You buy a property below its finished value, renovate it, rent it, then refinance into a long term loan sized on the new value so some or all of your cash comes back for the next purchase.
Is BRRRR still a good strategy?
It works when the refinance works. That means a realistic after-repair value supported by sold comps, rent that covers the full payment at about a 1.00 ratio, and enough time owned before the new value counts. When the all-in cost runs well above about 75% of the after-repair value, more cash stays in the deal.
How long do I have to wait to refinance a BRRRR property?
On most current DSCR programs I work with, about 6 months from the day you took title before the appraised value counts for a cash-out. Some programs are shorter and lend less. If you bought with cash, delayed financing can work sooner, sized on your cost.
Does the refinance pay for the rehab?
No. The DSCR loan at the end pays off what's on the property and can return equity. The rehab itself gets paid by your cash or a short term rehab loan.
How much cash can I get back on a BRRRR refinance?
The most it can return is the program's loan to value times the appraised value, minus your payoff and costs. On strong files, cash-out typically tops out around 75% of value on the programs I use. Run your numbers in the BRRRR calculator to see your exact figure.
Have a deal under contract or a rehab almost done? Run it through the BRRRR calculator, then the Readiness Check. If you want me to look at it, you can start at Apply Now, text me at (207) 615-7770, or email Travis@travis.mortgage. DSCR loans are for investment property only. Not everyone will qualify.
I'm Travis Penny, a Senior Mortgage Broker with Vision Mortgage, LLC. I help clients buy and refinance homes in Maine and Florida, and I arrange DSCR loans on investment and rental properties in 38 states. I started in 2004 and I'm still here.
